Back to Squawk list
  • 74

Study Finds Pilots’ Brains Work Differently

提交时间:
 
Medical science has now confirmed what your family and friends have been telling you since the first time you strapped in and maybe before that. Your brain works differently than that of non-flying folks and contrary to what those in your immediate bubble might think, that’s actually a good thing, well mostly. (www.avweb.com) 更多...

Sort type: [Top] [Newest]


Moviela
Ric Wernicke 19
Pilots are people that can process operation of complex electro-mechanical systems while applying deft control of the systems based on physical stimuli and a through understanding of the expected outcome of changes to the system.

The whole process can be summed up in three words:

Fly the airplane.
bbabis
bbabis 31
My wife has told me my brain is different for over 40 years. Don’t give her any more ammunition.
MikeMohle
Mike Mohle 3
I hear ya!
propman46
Well, if you'll excuse the pun, this seems like a "no-brainer." While we mere mortals spend most of our lives in a 2-dimentional world, pilots live in 3-dimentions. That's got to have an impact. It would be interesting to see if this holds true for scuba divers or submarine captains.
WhiteKnight77
WhiteKnight77 1
I know I was always able to find my way back to the boat or point of shore entry when I went diving, without the aid of a compass (though I did have one), on Okinawa. Diving near 3rd Recon was always a joy and had great visibility.
bbabis
bbabis 9
The article simply states that pilot’s brains may be different. That doesn’t necessarily mean better as many posters seam to assume. It could go either way. When they state time of useful consciousness at altitude, I see no correlation because I know many pilots who’s consciousness is not useful at sea level.
666adt
They mean "differently" AS "better"...in the context of flying a plane.
watkinssusan
a person in any given profession TRAINS for the specifics of that job,and the brain adapts to the training given..whether you are a doctor,a nurse,an engineer,a geologist,an IT person,an engineer or yes, a pilot..i disagre wuth the premise given in the article that a pilots brain works differently...almost all of the airline pilots i have met however,do seem to have the "i am a god" mentality,and they let you know it!!
RetiredCaptain
Jasper Buck 5
"...almost all of the airline pilots i have met however,do seem to have the "i am a god" mentality,and they let you know it!!"

Perhaps that's because so much more time nearer to God than thou. >;-)

Best

Capt J Buck

ATP DC-9 B757 B767
Flight Instructor
Ground Instructor
Aircraft Dispatcher
A&P Mechanic
Air Traffic Controller
FAA Aviation Safety Inspector (Ret.)
FAA certified accident investigator (Ret.)
ICAO Panel Member
Aviation Safety Consultant
Lib4ever
Wow, Captain Buck's accomplishments boggle the mind, don't they? How could anyone challenge his opinions when confronted with his dossier? He even left out a few things:

Vice Chairperson, Happy Valley PTA
Certified Xerox machine toner and drum changer
Licensed hedge trimmer and rose bush pruner
Dryer of dinner dishes
Lawn mower Frame and Powerplant Mechanic
Advisory Board member, Schnicklefritz Post 666, Boy Scouts of America
Three time bowler of a 300
Grand Admiral of the Fleet, Dinkins Bay Skiff-and-Dinghy Club
RetiredCaptain
Jasper Buck 1
Nope, sorry, none of those things. For your list I hire an appropriately trained person to complete the task. Except for drying the dishes, our Bosch dishwasher does that.

Best
Lib4ever
Ummmm... I believe you missed the point, Cap'n. But never mind, this is likely not the venue for broad humor.
LoriMiller
Lori Miller 3
And they’re probably talking to Him more also!
myriamrevelard
Yes pilots are gods...They live their dream, they are always happy.
rartac
Robert Artac 1
that's why I'm not an airline pilot.
WhiteKnight77
WhiteKnight77 1
What does it mean if you see stuff such as the protruding spike on a wooden roller coaster 10 years before you become an NDT inspector? ;)
LowOrbitTraveler01
Retired pilot here. 5 years Navy, 35 years airline. 22,843 hours.
Interesting read and comments.

My take is the pilot in command during flight is constantly making or changing decisions based upon the variable inputs.

Perhaps "The Pilot Brain" is a learned trait over time.

It seems to me my thinking off the aircraft is more linear.

I have heard the "I am God" comments and attitude. People handle command differently. During a flight and emergency the pilot in command decides a course of action that crew may not agree with. The crew is normally not directly responsible for any injuries or death.
A6SEA
Bill Butler 1
What Squadron? When?
xtoler
Larry Toler 4
Flying for a living isn't a job, it's a lifestyle. At least that's what I was told in F/A initial training. It really didn't feel like a job at all.
capcmdr
capcmdr 3
Flying is the fun part.. Gets a little difficult when someone is shooting at you!
thomafrancl
Thomas Francl 3
My mind has always been in the gutter so I guess that's why I'm not a pilot.
redbaron
Gordon Young 3
Good ole multi-tasking or mental-juggling..
DJFoxtrot
David Friesen 3
Study is on 26-year-olds (SD 3), with mean flight time 1200 hrs (SD 2400). It would be interesting to see results for say a 40-year-old with 15 000 hrs.
MikeMohle
Mike Mohle 3
Ah, so THAT'S it..... I will tell my wife.
joselmejia
Jose Mejia 2
All pilots have my utmost admiration!
canuck44
canuck44 2
The problem with papers like this is they are snapshots of individuals who are employed to an environment but because the study has no depth are these innate qualities or learned. more likely are they pilots who have not been washed out along the way and have not reached their Peter Principle level before obtaining their current status.
ronanmurph
ronanmurph 2
I like this study, though I don't think it has any groundbreaking science about how the brain works. It seems to support that piloting(and learning to pilot)an aircraft probably makes us use our brains more in certain ways than those with comparable education. It improves connectivity measured outside the cockpit environment. What it does not tell us is wether this has any effect on other functioning outside the cockpit, but interesting to speculate on this.

This reminds me of a story that perhaps helps us understand more about why this is so interesting - hope you may enjoy this read:
https://www.acaedu.net/cms/lib3/TX01001550/Centricity/Domain/518/Basho%20and%20the%20Fox.pdf
Bursk
Randall Bursk 2
My first time exposed to bananas was with a marine pilot instructor, ground school 1975. What followed was a 39 year airline career of International Flying both the line, training department. Total Bliss. Permanent Leave of Absence with COVID-19 finished my career. Thank all of you, hope for a better future.
dprcrna
That explains it! Being an anesthetist and having been told that anesthetists make good pilots because we have to monitor so many things at the same time and coordinate them for good results, this explains why my friends (and sometimes family) seem to think my brain works differently than theirs. (I just tell them it's the nootropics I take. Yeah, right.)
frequentflyguy
We knew that from this board LOL
bluejbamboo
Original report published in June 2020:
"These findings suggest that pilots might have better functional dynamics and cognitive flexibility".

..suggests .. might.
Junk science. Publish or perish.
But it is fun to speculate about ourselves ...
gkenney69
Jerry Kenney 2
We should be more concerned about the lack of brains of the non-pilots who design cockpit automation that overrules pilots and flies airplanes in to the ground. Pilot in command has been replaced by “programmer in command”.
ElliotCannon
Elliot Cannon 1
In about 100 years from now there won't be any pilots. LOL
waypoint66
David Rice 1
That will be here in way less than 100 years.
canuck44
canuck44 1
Think of how this theory could have been completely screwed up had they collected data from the last Tail Hook Convention in Vegas.
A6SEA
Bill Butler 1
Hah! We're all about the same once we get out of town....
A6SEA
Bill Butler 1
It's on the internet, it must be true.

Made In China. Caveat emptor.

If you would like a couple stories of pilots whose brains short-circuited.....
PlainSpeaking
Brent Bahler 1
And yet, that “wired differently” brain can easily fall prey to spatial disorientation when it should know better (i.e., trust your instruments).
jdries
Jim Ries 1
Heard the same about cab drivers a long time ago.
richardHelfand
Does "Flight Simulator" count?
msetera
Liberals' brains work differently too.
Moviela
Ric Wernicke 1
Yes, they think they won the Whitehouse.
Moviela
Ric Wernicke -1
Now let's see if pilots get the joke.
ElliotCannon
Elliot Cannon 0
Lets try and keep the political BS off of this site.
tongo
Dan Grelinger 1
Good advice Mr. Cannon! However, aren't you the author of this post?

"Not too long ago, President Donald "I know more than the generals" Trump insisted that the old steam catault should be used because EALS would be too expensive. I wonder where he got all his military experetise? Maybe from his Podiatrist."

It would seem pretty obvious that what you REALLY mean is:

"You are free to express your opinion if it agrees with mine. If it disagrees with mine, you are stupid."

That, dear friend, is typical liberalism.
JohnGiroux
John Giroux -1
Too bad there's no typical "conservatism" these days, just a bunch of lemmings who bow and pray to an absolute idiot who spews lies.
WhiteKnight77
WhiteKnight77 3
All politcians are liars.
tongo
Dan Grelinger 1
Two posts since you created your FlightAware account, and both of them contributed nothing constructive.

I look forward to your next pearls of wisdom.
JohnGiroux
John Giroux 0
Yeah, they WORK.. yours obviously doesn't..
Highflyer1950
Highflyer1950 1
You don’t a study, just ask any Flight Attendant?
RexBentley
Rex Bentley -1
Yeah like chimpanzee. Push button get banana
myriamrevelard
I admire pilots so much...

登录

还没有帐户吗? 现在就注册(免费),设置诸多自定义功能、航班提醒等等!
本网站使用cookie。您使用并继续浏览本网站,即表示您接受这一点。
退出
您知道FlightAware航班跟踪是由广告支持吗?
通过允许展示来自FlightAware.com的广告,您可以帮助我们使FlightAware保持免费。我们努力使我们的广告保持相关性,同时不显突兀,以创造一流的体验。在FlightAware上将广告加入白名单快捷而简单,或者请您考虑选择我们的高级帐户.
退出